Brotman Law June 27, 2024 32 min read

Strategies for Successfully Defending ERTC Audits in Pennsylvania: Key Tactics and Approaches

Essential Strategies for Successful ERTC Audit Defense in Pennsylvania

In Pennsylvania, where industries such as healthcare, manufacturing, and agriculture play vital roles in the economy, the Employee Retention Tax Credit (ERTC) stands as a lifeline for businesses grappling with the impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic. This federal initiative provides significant financial support by offering a refundable tax credit to companies that maintained their workforce despite economic challenges. However, accessing the benefits of the ERTC also exposes businesses to potential IRS audits. For Pennsylvania enterprises, comprehending the nuances of ERTC compliance is crucial to shield against audits and ensure uninterrupted access to the program's advantages. 

This article will delve into essential strategies for defending against ERTC audits tailored to Pennsylvania's unique economic landscape. It will emphasize the importance of proactive measures and highlight the indispensable role of tax attorneys in navigating these complex processes. 


ERTC Essentials for Pennsylvania Businesses 


Pennsylvania businesses can leverage the Employee Retention Tax Credit (ERTC) to offset financial hardships caused by significant declines in gross receipts or government-mandated suspensions of operations. Understanding the specific requirements and maintaining strict compliance protocols are crucial steps to qualify for this refundable tax credit and protect against potential audits. 


Impact of Statewide Measures on Pennsylvania's Business Landscape 

Throughout the COVID-19 pandemic, Pennsylvania enacted a series of statewide directives and programs aimed at addressing the wide spread disease. Understanding the ramifications of these directives on businesses is pivotal for substantiating your ERTC claim.  

  • Stay-at-Home Mandate: Pennsylvania implemented a statewide stay-at-home mandate, compelling non-essential businesses to either suspend operations or adapt practices to stem the spread of COVID-19.
  • Expanded Unemployment Benefits: Pennsylvania broadened unemployment benefits to offer additional support to individuals facing job losses or reduced hours due to the pandemic, indirectly affecting businesses' payroll management.
  • Sector-Specific Guidelines: The state issued guidelines tailored to specific industries to ensure safe resumption of operations, outlining protocols for social distancing, sanitation, and health measures. 
  • Regional Restrictions: Pennsylvania imposed regional restrictions based on COVID-19 transmission rates, impacting businesses differently across areas with varying infection rates and potentially imposing operational limitations to contain the virus's spread.
  • Expansion of Paid Sick Leave: Legislative measures were enacted to expand paid sick leave benefits for employees affected by COVID-19, influencing businesses' HR policies and sick leave management practices.
  • Workplace Safety Protocols: Pennsylvania mandated workplace safety measures, including mask mandates, social distancing requirements, and enhanced sanitation protocols, to safeguard employees and customers across various sectors.
  • Operational Guidelines: The state issued comprehensive guidelines for businesses, outlining requirements and recommendations for safe and compliant business operations during the pandemic, such as occupancy limits and enhanced cleaning protocols.

In summary, the implementation of statewide directives and assistance programs in Pennsylvania aimed to alleviate the impact of COVID-19 on businesses, but also impacted business operations. Documenting these orders and their impacts on your business will go a long way in an ERTC audit. 

Impact of COVID-19 on Pennsylvania's Top Cities 

As the COVID-19 pandemic swept across Pennsylvania, its impact varied significantly across the state's top cities. From the bustling streets of Philadelphia to the vibrant tech hub of Pittsburgh and the political center of Harrisburg, each city faced unique challenges that reverberated through its local economy. In this context, understanding how the pandemic affected businesses in Pennsylvania's urban centers is essential for navigating the complexities of programs like the Employee Retention Tax Credit (ERTC). By examining the specific impacts on cities like Philadelphia, Pittsburgh, and Harrisburg, businesses can better prepare to address eligibility criteria and potential audit triggers related to the ERTC. 

  • Philadelphia: As Pennsylvania's largest city, Philadelphia encountered a range of challenges due to the COVID-19 pandemic. The city's vibrant tourism and hospitality industry, centered around historical landmarks and cultural attractions, suffered considerable setbacks from travel restrictions and limitations on public gatherings. Moreover, the closure of public offices and service providers disrupted the operations of businesses dependent on government contracts and services.
  • Pittsburgh: Renowned for its strong emphasis on healthcare and technology, Pittsburgh faced distinctive hurdles during the pandemic. The closure of educational institutions and healthcare facilities disrupted the city's education and healthcare sectors, impacting ancillary businesses such as bookstores, medical supply companies, and healthcare service providers. Additionally, restrictions on elective medical procedures and non-essential healthcare services further strained the local healthcare industry.
  • Harrisburg: Serving as the capital city of Pennsylvania, Harrisburg experienced significant economic repercussions from COVID-19. The decline in consumer spending and foot traffic resulted in a notable downturn in the retail and hospitality sectors, affecting restaurants, shops, and entertainment venues. Furthermore, restrictions on public gatherings and events had a substantial impact on the local arts and cultural scene, which heavily relies on performances, exhibitions, and festivals for revenue.
  • Allentown: Manufacturing and Healthcare Sectors. Allentown, with a strong base in manufacturing and healthcare, faced significant challenges during the pandemic. Manufacturing facilities had to reduce capacity or shut down temporarily due to social distancing measures, impacting production lines and supply chains. The healthcare sector, while experiencing increased demand, also faced immense pressure to manage resources and safeguard employees. Businesses should document operational disruptions, changes in manufacturing schedules, and financial impacts due to decreased productivity, along with measures taken to maintain healthcare services and protect workers.
  • Erie: Tourism and Service Industries. Erie, known for its attractions like Presque Isle State Park and vibrant lakefront area, saw a drastic reduction in tourism, which severely affected the local hospitality industry, including hotels, restaurants, and leisure facilities. These establishments had to pivot to offering limited services or shut down completely during lockdowns. Records should include the duration and financial impact of closures, adaptations to business models such as implementing takeout and delivery services, and efforts to retain employees despite reduced operations.
  • Reading: Retail and Small Businesses. Reading's retail sector, particularly in downtown areas and local malls, experienced severe disruptions as non-essential businesses were forced to close temporarily. Small businesses struggled with maintaining cash flow and had to quickly adapt to online sales platforms to reach their customers. Documentation for ERTC claims should include detailed accounts of lost revenue, costs associated with moving to digital platforms, changes in customer interaction, and strategies to manage and retain staff during this transition.
  • Bethlehem: Arts, Culture, and Education. Bethlehem, with a rich arts scene and home to several colleges, faced cancellations of cultural events and shifts to remote learning. This not only affected institutions directly but also had a ripple effect on businesses that cater to arts patrons and the student population. Documentation should focus on the impact of event cancellations, shifts in university operations, loss of revenue from arts and educational activities, and how these entities adapted to maintain engagement and support their employees.
  • Scranton: Logistics and Distribution. Scranton, serving as an important hub in Northeast Pennsylvania for logistics and distribution, experienced both challenges and opportunities. While some companies saw a surge in demand due to increases in online shopping, others dealt with disruptions in the supply chains and staffing issues due to health concerns. Companies need to maintain records detailing operational adjustments, changes in workforce management, financial impacts of increased or decreased demand, and health and safety measures implemented to protect employees.

These city-specific impacts underscore the diverse challenges faced by businesses across Pennsylvania's urban centers. Understanding these dynamics is crucial for businesses to effectively navigate ERTC eligibility criteria and potential audit triggers. 

Typical Reasons for IRS ERTC Audits in Pennsylvania:

Navigating the complexities of tax regulations such as the Employee Retention Tax Credit (ERTC) is vital for businesses in Pennsylvania seeking to maintain compliance and financial stability. Understanding the common triggers for IRS ERTC audits is paramount in this endeavor. By identifying these triggers upfront, businesses can take proactive measures to mitigate audit risks, ensure accurate filings, and safeguard their operations from unnecessary scrutiny. 

  • Inconsistent Tax Filings: Discrepancies or inconsistencies in tax filings, particularly related to ERTC claims, may raise red flags for IRS auditors.
  • Large ERTC Claims: Businesses making unusually large ERTC claims relative to their size or industry may attract closer IRS scrutiny.
  • Random Selection: Some audits occur randomly, without any specific trigger, as part of the IRS's routine monitoring and enforcement activities.
  • Lack of Documentation: Insufficient or incomplete documentation to support ERTC claims, such as payroll records, financial statements, or proof of operations suspension, can lead to audit risks.
  • Misinterpretation of Eligibility Criteria: Businesses misunderstanding or misapplying the eligibility criteria for the ERTC, such as the requirements related to gross receipts decline or government-ordered suspensions, may inadvertently trigger audits.
  • Mathematical Errors: Errors in calculating the ERTC amount, whether due to misunderstanding the calculation method or making mathematical mistakes, can invite IRS scrutiny.
  • Inadequate Record-Keeping: Poor record-keeping practices, including failure to maintain detailed records of qualified wages, health plan expenses, or operational changes, may increase audit vulnerability.
  • Suspicious Patterns: Unusual patterns or trends in ERTC claims, such as sudden spikes or inconsistencies over time, could raise suspicions and trigger audits.
  • Previous Audit History: Businesses with a history of compliance issues or past audits, whether related to ERTC or other tax matters, may face increased audit risks.
  • Industry Trends: IRS may target industries or sectors experiencing significant economic challenges or regulatory scrutiny, making businesses in these sectors more susceptible to audits.

In conclusion, understanding and addressing the common triggers for IRS ERTC audits are essential components of prudent tax management for businesses in Pennsylvania. By maintaining meticulous records, adhering to eligibility criteria, and seeking professional guidance when needed, businesses can minimize the likelihood of audits and uphold compliance with confidence. 

Frequent Causes of IRS ERTC Audits in Pennsylvania:

When navigating the Employee Retention Tax Credit (ERTC) in Oregon, businesses should steer clear of potential errors, such as: 

  • Misinterpretation of Eligibility Criteria: Misunderstanding the specific requirements for demonstrating economic hardship or operational suspension as outlined in the ERTC guidelines.
  • Lack of Comprehensive Documentation: Failing to maintain thorough records to support the ERTC claim, particularly regarding payroll records and operational status during the relevant periods.
  • Calculation Mistakes: Errors in determining the accurate credit amount owed, often stemming from misconceptions about the complexities of tax laws and regulations. 

Critical Documentation for ERTC Audit Defense in Pennsylvania 

In readiness for confronting an ERTC audit in Pennsylvania, businesses must ensure the availability of critical documentation, encompassing: 

  • Thorough Employment Records: Supplying exhaustive evidence of employee retention and adherence to payroll practices throughout the pertinent periods.
  • Precise Financial Statements: Providing transparent insights into the financial ramifications endured by the business, particularly attributing losses to COVID-19-related challenges.
  • Government and Operational Documentation: Furnishing documented evidence showcasing compliance with state and federal COVID-19 regulations, thereby demonstrating adherence to operational limitations and safety protocols. 

The Role of Tax Attorneys in ERTC Audit Defense in Pennsylvania 

In Pennsylvania, tax attorneys assume a pivotal role in navigating businesses through the ERTC audit process, offering indispensable assistance that includes: 

  • Interpreting ERTC Regulations: Providing expert interpretations of intricate tax laws, aiding Pennsylvania businesses in grasping eligibility criteria and compliance requirements comprehensively.
  • Facilitating Audit Preparation: Assisting in the meticulous organization and presentation of vital documentation, ensuring businesses are well-prepared to address IRS inquiries with precision.
  • Advocating for Businesses in IRS Interactions: Serving as representatives for businesses in all communications with the IRS, from initial inquiries to formal audit procedures, advocating for their interests and rights throughout the process. 

Proactive Strategies for Audit Readiness in Pennsylvania 

To preemptively mitigate the risk of audits and reduce their potential repercussions, businesses in Pennsylvania are encouraged to adopt proactive measures: 

  • Routine Documentation Reviews: Conduct regular assessments of all ERTC-related records to ensure their completeness and accuracy, thereby minimizing the likelihood of audit discrepancies.
  • Continuous Legal and Financial Consultation: Maintain ongoing communication with tax advisors to stay abreast of evolving ERTC regulations and tax laws pertinent to Pennsylvania, enabling proactive adjustments to compliance measures.  
  • Mock Audit Drills: Implement simulated audit exercises to replicate IRS scrutiny scenarios, allowing businesses to identify and address any deficiencies in their audit trail proactively, fortifying their defense against potential audit triggers.

Cultivating a Compliance-Focused Culture in Pennsylvania

Promoting a corporate culture that emphasizes meticulous record-keeping and unwavering adherence to tax regulations is paramount in Pennsylvania. This entails implementing employee training programs, regularly updating compliance protocols, and establishing robust internal oversight mechanisms to ensure compliance at all levels of the organization. 

Conclusion: Ensuring ERTC Compliance in Pennsylvania

In Pennsylvania, managing ERTC claims transcends mere financial relief; it entails maintaining ongoing compliance with tax laws and preparedness for potential IRS audits. By fostering a culture of compliance, maintaining detailed records, and collaborating with seasoned tax professionals, businesses can effectively navigate ERTC audits while positioning themselves for long-term success in Pennsylvania's ever-evolving business landscape. 


"Sam is a wonderful, results-oriented and extremely knowledgeable and talented attorney, who really has 'heart' in working on behalf of his clients, and explains options in a straightforward, respectful manner. He has assisted us with great outcomes which have added to our quality of life. I would not hesitate to recommend Sam for his services as he is an ethical, personable and expert attorney in his field. You will likely not be disappointed with Sam's work ethic, approach and his efforts."

-Aileen Dwight, Licensed Clinical Social Worker & Psychotherapist

Last updated: July 8, 2024

Receive the Best of
Brotman Law

Get this topic delivered straight to your inbox.

New call-to-action



Our best stuff: secrets, tax saving tools, and tax defense strategies from the braintrust at Brotman Law.

  • Expanded benefits during your first consultation with the firm.
  • Priority appointment scheduling and appointment times.
  • Complementary access to our firm’s concierge services.
  • Receive updates and “insider only” tax strategies and tactics.
  • And many more benefits.

Not Sure Where to Start?

Step 1 Start Here

Start Here

These ten big ideas will change the way you think about your taxes and your business.

Start Here

Step 2 Learn About Your Situation

Learn About Your Situation

Find the articles and videos you need to make the right tax decisions in the learning center.

Visit the Learning Center

Step 3 Explore Our Services

Explore Our Services

It is not just about what we do, but who we are, why we do it, and how that benefits you.

View All Services

Step 4 Get Your Game Plan

Get Your Game Plan

Meet with us to outline your strategy. No further obligation, 100% money-back guarantee.

Book an Action Plan