Brotman Law May 5, 2024 13 min read

Comprehensive ERTC Audit Defense Strategies for Idaho Businesses

A Tax Attorney's Guide to Defending ERTC Audits for Idaho Taxpayers

For businesses across Idaho, from the bustling urban centers of Boise to the agricultural hubs like Twin Falls and the manufacturing sectors of Coeur d'Alene, the Employee Retention Tax Credit (ERTC) has been a critical support mechanism during the COVID-19 pandemic. This federal tax relief helps businesses that managed to retain employees despite the economic disruptions caused by COVID-19. However, with this benefit comes the responsibility of ensuring compliance to avoid potential IRS audits.

This guide will explore effective ERTC audit defense strategies, emphasizing Idaho businesses' specific needs. It will also discuss the role of tax attorneys in ensuring robust audit defense and how local directives across Idaho’s major cities have influenced ERTC eligibility and compliance.

Understanding the ERTC in Idaho’s Context

The ERTC offers a refundable tax credit to businesses that either experienced a significant decline in gross receipts or were subject to government-mandated operational suspensions. In Idaho, different cities faced varying degrees of restrictions, affecting businesses uniquely based on their location and sector.

COVID-19 Idaho State Mandates That Businesses May Be Able To Use in The ERTC Audit Defense

In Idaho, a series of significant COVID-19 related orders were issued between 2020 and 2021, each having a profound impact on local businesses and their ability to claim benefits under the Employee Retention Tax Credit (ERTC). These directives, which varied from mandatory closures to operational restrictions, were essential for managing public health but also posed various challenges and opportunities for businesses striving to maintain their workforce and navigate the complexities of ERTC audits.

  • Statewide Stay-Home Order (March 25, 2020): This order required all non-essential businesses to cease in-person operations. It led to widespread business disruptions, making it crucial for companies to understand their eligibility for the ERTC as they faced significant operational reductions.
  • State of Emergency Declaration (March 13, 2020): The early declaration enabled Idaho to mobilize resources and enforce measures affecting all business operations across the state. This situation influenced businesses' ability to maintain their workforce, directly impacting their qualification for ERTC during the periods of enhanced restrictions.
  • Public Health Emergency Extension (April 15, 2020): By extending the public health emergency, Idaho allowed ongoing support measures for businesses, which continued to affect their operational capacities and ERTC claims, emphasizing the need for meticulous documentation and compliance.
  • Activation of the Idaho National Guard (Multiple times from March 2020): The National Guard's activation to support the state’s COVID-19 response indirectly supported businesses, particularly in the healthcare and essential supply chains, helping maintain operations that were crucial for ERTC claims.
  • Four-Stage Idaho Rebounds Plan (April 23, 2020): This phased plan for reopening set specific benchmarks for businesses to resume operations gradually. Each phase had implications for ERTC claims, as partial operations allowed businesses to begin recalculating their eligibility and benefits under the tax credit.
  • Localized Mask Mandates (2020-2021): While not a state-mandated order, many local jurisdictions, including Boise, implemented mask mandates that affected customer-facing businesses. Compliance with such mandates was crucial for safely continuing operations and thus maintaining eligibility for the ERTC.
  • Limitations on Public Gatherings (Various times): Restrictions on the size of gatherings impacted venues and event-oriented businesses, which had direct consequences on their revenues and staff retention strategies, affecting their ERTC claims.
  • Financial Assistance Initiatives for Small Businesses (Starting April 2020): Idaho launched several financial assistance programs to help small businesses keep their workforce employed. These funds were complementary to the ERTC and provided critical financial support to eligible businesses.
  • Ban on Vaccine Passports (April 7, 2021): This order prohibited businesses from requiring proof of vaccination from customers, affecting how businesses could operate safely while retaining their employees. It added another layer of complexity for businesses in managing public health requirements and ERTC eligibility.
  • Specific Guidance for Continued Business Operations Under Stay-Home Orders: The state provided detailed guidelines on which businesses could continue operations and under what safety protocols during the stay-home order. Adherence to these guidelines was crucial for businesses to claim ERTC, as it directly tied to maintaining payroll while operational.

Local COVID-19 Directives Across Idaho and Their Impact on ERTC Eligibility

The varying COVID-19 directives across Idaho's localities significantly influenced business operations, each with unique implications for Employee Retention Tax Credit (ERTC) eligibility.

  • Boise: Throughout 2020, Boise businesses, particularly in the retail and service industries, grappled with multiple stay-at-home orders and capacity restrictions. These measures forced many businesses to operate at reduced capacity or temporarily shut down, directly impacting their revenue streams and affecting their qualifications for the ERTC.
  • Idaho Falls: In Idaho Falls, local mandates enforced social distancing protocols that particularly impacted the hospitality and retail sectors. Restaurants, cafes, and shops had to alter their layouts and service models, which often led to reduced customer intake and altered operating hours, thereby affecting their ability to maintain staff levels and meet ERTC requirements.
  • Twin Falls: The agricultural sector in Twin Falls encountered significant challenges due to supply chain disruptions and a downturn in demand from key buyers like restaurants and hotels. These issues not only impacted produce sales but also affected the employment rates within these businesses, crucial for ERTC claims.
  • Coeur d’Alene: Known for its tourism and vibrant manufacturing sector, Coeur d'Alene saw stringent travel restrictions and operational capacity limits. These restrictions hit during peak tourist seasons, drastically reducing income for local businesses dependent on tourist dollars and disrupting manufacturing outputs, thereby influencing their ERTC eligibility.

  • Lewiston: In Lewiston, where the paper and timber industry plays a significant role, businesses faced operational challenges due to health regulations that limited workforce capacity in factories and on-site jobs. The reduction in workforce directly impacted their production schedules and financial health, which are critical factors in qualifying for the ERTC.

Navigating ERTC Eligibility and IRS ERC Audit Preparedness:

These orders collectively guided businesses through a tumultuous period, with each directive introducing different challenges and considerations for ERTC eligibility. To navigate this landscape effectively, businesses needed to stay informed about the evolving regulations, maintain rigorous documentation of their operational statuses and workforce changes, and prepare thoroughly for potential audits. Proactive measures, including routine internal reviews and mock audits, became essential strategies for businesses aiming to capitalize on the ERTC and ensure compliance with its stipulations.

Understanding Common ERTC Claim Mistakes:

Many Idaho businesses have stumbled over common pitfalls when filing for the ERTC. A frequent error is the failure to document revenue declines adequately. This particular oversight can complicate substantiating a company's eligibility for the credit, as clear financial records are indispensable for demonstrating the direct impact of the pandemic on business operations. Additionally, misinterpreting eligibility requirements—especially concerning what constitutes a partial suspension of operations—has led some businesses astray. This is often compounded by the diversity of industries in Idaho, where the specifics of what disruptions qualify can vary greatly.

Moreover, maintaining meticulous records of employee counts and pay rates is paramount. These records are essential not just for proving the retention of employees under the terms of the ERTC but also for ensuring that all claimed credits are justifiable under scrutiny.

The Backbone of a Successful ERC Audit Defense: Essential Documentation

The foundation of any robust ERTC audit defense is comprehensive documentation. Detailed payroll records that demonstrate consistent employment and correct payment to eligible employees are crucial. Equally important are financial statements and revenue reports that clearly map out the periods of revenue decline correlated directly to pandemic-induced operational disruptions. Documentation on how local government mandates specifically affected business operations can also provide contextual support during an audit, illustrating compliance and the impact of such directives on the business.

The Role of Tax Attorneys in ERTC Audit Defense

Tax attorneys in Idaho play an indispensable role in navigating the ERTC landscape. Their expertise in local and federal tax laws makes them invaluable advisors on compliance, ensuring that businesses understand and correctly apply complex regulations. In preparation for potential audits, tax attorneys are instrumental in organizing and vetting all necessary documentation to meet IRS standards. Perhaps most critically, during audits, they represent businesses, advocating effectively on their behalf and managing communications with the IRS to secure the best possible outcomes.

Proactive Measures to Fortify Against IRS Audits

To safeguard against potential audits, proactive strategies are essential for any Idaho business taking advantage of the ERTC. Regular compliance checks can help ensure that ERTC claims and the supporting documentation remain accurate and complete. Engaging with local tax professionals for ongoing consultations offers businesses a way to stay abreast of changes in tax law or ERTC guidelines. Additionally, conducting internal or external preemptive audits can unearth potential issues, allowing businesses to address them before the IRS does, thereby reducing the risk of negative audit outcomes.

Conclusion: Ensuring Audit-Ready Defenses for ERTC Claims Across Idaho

For Idaho businesses, effectively managing ERTC claims is about more than just enjoying the tax benefits. It's about ensuring these claims are defensible under IRS scrutiny. By understanding local impacts, maintaining detailed documentation, and leveraging the expertise of tax attorneys, businesses across Idaho can confidently navigate ERTC audits. This proactive and informed approach is key to leveraging ERTC benefits fully while ensuring compliance and readiness for any IRS audits that may come their way.


"Sam is a wonderful, results-oriented and extremely knowledgeable and talented attorney, who really has 'heart' in working on behalf of his clients, and explains options in a straightforward, respectful manner. He has assisted us with great outcomes which have added to our quality of life. I would not hesitate to recommend Sam for his services as he is an ethical, personable and expert attorney in his field. You will likely not be disappointed with Sam's work ethic, approach and his efforts."

-Aileen Dwight, Licensed Clinical Social Worker & Psychotherapist

Last updated: May 18, 2024

Receive the Best of
Brotman Law

Get this topic delivered straight to your inbox.

New call-to-action



Our best stuff: secrets, tax saving tools, and tax defense strategies from the braintrust at Brotman Law.

  • Expanded benefits during your first consultation with the firm.
  • Priority appointment scheduling and appointment times.
  • Complementary access to our firm’s concierge services.
  • Receive updates and “insider only” tax strategies and tactics.
  • And many more benefits.

Not Sure Where to Start?

Step 1 Start Here

Start Here

These ten big ideas will change the way you think about your taxes and your business.

Start Here

Step 2 Learn About Your Situation

Learn About Your Situation

Find the articles and videos you need to make the right tax decisions in the learning center.

Visit the Learning Center

Step 3 Explore Our Services

Explore Our Services

It is not just about what we do, but who we are, why we do it, and how that benefits you.

View All Services

Step 4 Get Your Game Plan

Get Your Game Plan

Meet with us to outline your strategy. No further obligation, 100% money-back guarantee.

Book an Action Plan